Introduction

When it comes to managing human resources (HR), companies are increasingly turning to Human Resource Information Systems (HRIS) to streamline processes and enhance employee engagement. In this comparison, we delve into two popular HRIS tools: Sesame HR and Paylocity. Sesame HR simplifies and automates routine HR processes, making it an invaluable ally for managers, executives, and HR managers looking to save time and focus on improving employee experience. In contrast, Paylocity offers a comprehensive product suite that enables professionals to make strategic decisions regarding benefits, core HR, payroll, talent, and workforce management while fostering a modern workplace and boosting employee engagement. Comparing these tools can help you determine which solution is best suited for your organization's needs.

​

Sesame HR Overview

Sesame HR is a tool designed to digitize and automate routine HR tasks, enabling managers to concentrate on employee experience rather than administrative work.

​

Key Features

1. Time and Attendance Tracking: Simplifies time tracking with digital punch clocks and integrates effortlessly with payroll systems.
2. Leave Management: Automates leave requests and approvals, offering a seamless experience for both employees and managers.
3. Employee Onboarding: Streamlines the onboarding process through automated checklists, reducing manual intervention and ensuring a smooth experience for new hires.
4. Performance Management: Facilitates performance reviews, enabling managers to set goals and track employee progress efficiently.
5. Document Management: Centralizes all employee-related documents, making it easy to store, access, and share vital documents securely.
6. Employee Self-Service Portal: Allows employees to access their information, request time off, and view their schedules, reducing the load on HR personnel.
7. HR Analytics: Provides insightful analytics and reporting to help managers make data-driven decisions.

​

Paylocity Overview

Paylocity offers a unified platform that empowers professionals to make strategic HR decisions while promoting employee engagement and a modern work culture.

​

Key Features

1. Payroll Management: Provides a robust payroll system that ensures compliance, accuracy, and timely payments.
2. Benefits Administration: Simplifies benefits management, allowing employees to easily enroll and manage their benefits.
3. Talent Management: Offers tools for recruiting, onboarding, and performance management to support the entire employee lifecycle.
4. Time and Labor Management: Automates time tracking, scheduling, and labor allocation, helping to reduce administrative overhead.
5. Employee Self-Service Portal: Empowers employees with self-service capabilities for managing their HR information, benefits, and time-off requests.
6. Workforce Management: Includes comprehensive tools for managing workforce operations, ensuring alignment with organizational goals.
7. HR Analytics and Reporting: Delivers powerful analytics and reporting capabilities, enabling managers to make data-informed decisions.
8. Mobile App: Provides a mobile application that extends the HRIS functionality to smartphones, offering flexibility and convenience for both employees and managers.

​

Similarities

Sesame HR and Paylocity share several similarities as HRIS tools designed to streamline HR processes and enhance employee engagement:

​

1. Employee Self-Service: Both platforms offer a self-service portal where employees can manage their personal information, request time off, and access relevant documents.
2. Time and Attendance Tracking: Each tool simplifies time tracking, ensuring accurate records and reducing manual errors.
3. Leave Management: Both systems automate leave requests and approvals, enhancing efficiency and reducing administrative workload.
4. Performance Management: Each platform includes tools for performance reviews, goal setting, and tracking employee progress.
5. Document Management: Both offer secure, centralized storage and easy access to employee-related documents.
6. HR Analytics: Both tools provide analytics and reporting capabilities to support data-driven decision-making.
7. Mobile Access: Both Sesame HR and Paylocity offer mobile access, allowing employees and managers to use HR functionalities on the go.

​

Differences

While Sesame HR and Paylocity share common features, they also have distinct differences that set them apart:

​

1. Payroll Management: Paylocity offers a comprehensive payroll management system integrated into its platform, ensuring accurate and compliant payroll processes. In contrast, Sesame HR primarily focuses on other HR functionalities and does not provide a dedicated payroll system.
2. Benefits Administration: Paylocity includes robust benefits administration tools, making it easier for employees to enroll and manage their benefits. Sesame HR, on the other hand, does not have extensive benefits management capabilities.
3. Talent Management: Paylocity offers a full suite of talent management tools, covering recruitment, onboarding, and ongoing performance management. Sesame HR primarily focuses on performance management and onboarding but lacks comprehensive talent management features.
4. Workforce Management: Paylocity provides extensive workforce management tools to align labor needs with organizational goals. Sesame HR focuses more on digitizing routine HR processes rather than comprehensive workforce management.
5. Mobile App Robustness: While both offer mobile access, Paylocity's mobile app is noted for its extensive functionality, which includes payroll management, benefits administration, and talent management features. Sesame HR’s mobile access mainly focuses on self-service, time tracking, and document management.
6. User Interface and Experience: Sesame HR is known for its intuitive and user-friendly interface, making it easy for HR managers and employees to navigate. Paylocity’s interface, while comprehensive, can be perceived as more complex due to the broader range of features and functionalities.

​

Pros and Cons

Sesame HR

Pros:

• Intuitive and user-friendly interface
• Excellent time and attendance tracking features
• Robust document management capabilities
• Effective performance management tools
• Automation of routine HR processes

​

Cons:

• Lacks a comprehensive payroll management system
• Limited benefits administration features
• Does not have full-suite talent management functionality
• Workforce management tools are not as extensive as some competitors

​

Paylocity

Pros:

• Comprehensive payroll management system
• Robust benefits administration and talent management features
• Extensive workforce management tools
• Powerful mobile app with wide-ranging functionalities
• Strong HR analytics and reporting capabilities

​

Cons:

• User interface can be complex due to feature richness
• May require more training for effective use
• Higher cost may be prohibitive for smaller businesses
• Some users report customer support can be slow to respond

​

Use Cases

Sesame HR

1. Small to Mid-sized Businesses: Ideal for companies looking to automate routine HR tasks and focus on improving employee experience without needing a comprehensive payroll system.
2. Companies Prioritizing Employee Experience: Perfect for organizations that want to streamline performance management, document management, and employee onboarding.
3. HR Departments Seeking User-Friendly Solutions: Great for HR teams that need an intuitive system to manage time tracking, leave management, and self-service options.

​

Paylocity

1. Medium to Large-sized Companies: Suitable for organizations looking for a unified platform that covers payroll, benefits, and talent management extensively.
2. Businesses with Complex Payroll Needs: Ideal for companies needing robust payroll management to ensure compliance and accuracy.
3. Organizations Focusing on Comprehensive HR Management: Excellent for companies that want a full-suite solution covering workforce management, HR analytics, and extensive self-service options for employees.

​

Conclusion

In comparing Sesame HR and Paylocity, it is evident that both tools offer substantial benefits depending on the needs of your organization. Sesame HR excels in simplifying and automating routine HR processes with an intuitive interface, making it ideal for small to mid-sized companies focused on enhancing employee experience without the need for extensive payroll and talent management features. On the other hand, Paylocity provides a comprehensive HRIS solution with robust payroll, benefits, and talent management capabilities, making it well-suited for medium to large-sized organizations with more complex HR needs.

​

Choosing between Sesame HR and Paylocity ultimately depends on your organization's specific requirements. If your primary goal is to automate routine HR tasks and focus on employee experience with an easy-to-use platform, Sesame HR could be the best fit. If you are looking for a more comprehensive solution that covers payroll, benefits, workforce management, and offers extensive analytics, Paylocity would likely be the better choice.