Introduction

​

Navigating the landscape of Human Resource Information Systems (HRIS) is crucial for organizations looking to optimize their employee management processes. Choosing the right tool can significantly impact operational efficiency, employee satisfaction, and overall business performance. In this comparison, we’ll delve into JumpCloud and Breathe, two prominent HRIS tools designed to cater to different geographical regions and organizational needs.

​

JumpCloud helps IT teams and managed service providers (MSPs) Make Work Happen® by centralizing the management of user identities and devices. It enables small and medium-sized enterprises to adopt Zero Trust security models. Used by over 200,000 organizations, including notable names like GoFundMe, Grab, Beyond Finance, and TechStars, JumpCloud has raised over $400M from leading investors, establishing itself as a major player in the HRIS domain.

​

On the other hand, Breathe is a multi-award-winning, simple, and secure people software tailored for UK and Australian SMEs. It digitizes core people processes, saving time, ensuring peace of mind, and enabling businesses to operate smoothly regardless of their location. By transitioning core HR processes online, Breathe provides a user-friendly solution for businesses looking for a hassle-free HRIS experience.

​

JumpCloud Overview

​

Key Features

​

JumpCloud offers a comprehensive suite of features designed to centralize and streamline the management of employee identities and devices:

​

• Centralized Identity Management: Simplifies the management of user credentials and access permissions across different systems and applications.
• Device Management: Provides a unified platform to manage various endpoints, including laptops, desktops, servers, and mobile devices.
• Zero Trust Security: Enhances security by verifying the identity of users and the integrity of their devices before granting access.
• Cross-Platform Compatibility: Supports Windows, macOS, and Linux, ensuring seamless integration across diverse IT environments.
• Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA): Adds an extra layer of security by requiring multiple forms of verification.
• Unified Directory: Consolidates user directories across different services, including cloud and on-premises systems.
• Single Sign-On (SSO): Simplifies access by allowing users to authenticate once and gain access to multiple applications.
• Policy Enforcement: Facilitates the implementation of security policies across devices and users.

​

Breathe Overview

​

Key Features

​

Breathe focuses on delivering an intuitive HRIS experience, emphasizing simplicity and security for SMEs:

​

• Employee Database: Centralizes employee records, making it easier to manage and access personnel information.
• Leave Management: Streamlines the process of requesting and approving leaves, with a built-in tracking system.
• Performance Management: Facilitates regular performance reviews, goal setting, and feedback.
• Document Management: Allows secure storage and sharing of important HR documents.
• Reporting and Analytics: Provides insightful reports on various HR metrics, helping in data-driven decision-making.
• Onboarding and Offboarding: Simplifies the process of integrating new employees and smoothly handling exits.
• Compliance Management: Ensures that the organization adheres to local labor laws and regulations.
• Employee Self-Service: Empowers employees to manage their personal information, leave requests, and other HR-related tasks through an intuitive portal.

​

Similarities

​

JumpCloud and Breathe share several key characteristics as HRIS tools, despite their different target markets and primary functionalities:

​

• Centralized Management: Both platforms offer a centralized system for managing employee information and HR processes.
• Security Features: Each tool places a strong emphasis on security, ensuring the protection of sensitive employee data.
• Scalability: Designed to grow with the organization, accommodating increasing numbers of employees and expanding business operations.
• User-Friendly Interface: Both JumpCloud and Breathe focus on providing intuitive user interfaces that simplify complex HR tasks.
• Compliance Support: Each platform includes features to help organizations stay compliant with relevant laws and regulations.
• Automation Capabilities: Automation of routine HR tasks is a core feature, reducing manual effort and increasing efficiency.

​

Differences

​

While JumpCloud and Breathe have several similarities, they also cater to distinct needs and functionalities, which sets them apart:

​

• Core Focus: JumpCloud is primarily focused on identity and device management with robust security features, whereas Breathe emphasizes comprehensive HR processes, including leave management, performance reviews, and compliance tracking.
• Geographical Targeting: JumpCloud has a global reach with a significant presence across various industries, while Breathe is specifically tailored to the HR requirements of UK and Australian SMEs.
• Integration Ecosystem: JumpCloud offers extensive integration capabilities with a variety of IT systems and applications, supporting a wider range of technical environments. Breathe, while offering integration options, is more focused on integrating with HR-specific tools and platforms.
• Device Management: JumpCloud provides advanced device management capabilities, which are not present in Breathe.
• Complexity and Customization: JumpCloud offers more complex, customizable solutions suited for IT-intensive environments, while Breathe focuses on simplicity and ease of use for HR tasks.

​

Pros and Cons

​

JumpCloud

​

Pros:

• Comprehensive identity and access management features.
• Extensive integration capabilities with various IT systems.
• Provides a robust Zero Trust security model.
• Supports cross-platform environments (Windows, macOS, Linux).
• Centralized directory service simplifies user management.

​

Cons:

• May require more technical expertise to set up and maintain.
• Overkill for organizations looking for simple HR process automation without extensive IT needs.
• Higher upfront investment compared to simpler HRIS tools.

​

Breathe

​

Pros:

• User-friendly interface tailored for HR tasks.
• Comprehensive HR process automation (leave management, performance reviews, etc.).
• Specifically designed for small to medium-sized enterprises.
• Affordable pricing model geared towards SMEs.
• Simplifies compliance with local labor laws and regulations.

​

Cons:

• Limited device management capabilities.
• Focused primarily on the UK and Australian markets, which may limit functionality for global companies.
• Less suitable for organizations needing robust IT identity management features.

​

Use Cases

​

JumpCloud

​

JumpCloud is ideal for organizations that:

• Require a robust identity and access management system.
• Need to manage a diverse array of devices and operating systems.
• Operate within industries demanding stringent security measures.
• Have a significant IT infrastructure requiring centralized management.
• Are looking to adopt a Zero Trust security model.

​

Breathe

​

Breathe is best suited for companies that:

• Need an easy-to-use HRIS for managing basic HR processes.
• Operate within the UK or Australian markets and need to ensure compliance with local regulations.
• Are small to medium-sized enterprises looking for an affordable HRIS solution.
• Require a simple and straightforward solution for leave management, performance reviews, and employee records.
• Are transitioning from paper-based HR processes to a digital platform.

​

Conclusion

​

When comparing JumpCloud and Breathe, it's clear that each tool excels in different areas, catering to distinct business needs. JumpCloud offers a sophisticated solution for identity and device management, making it ideal for IT-heavy environments that require advanced security and integration capabilities. Its Zero Trust security features and extensive cross-platform support are particularly beneficial for organizations with complex IT infrastructures.

​

Conversely, Breathe stands out as an accessible, user-friendly HRIS designed for small to medium-sized enterprises in the UK and Australia. Its focus on core HR processes like leave management, performance tracking, and employee self-service makes it an excellent choice for businesses seeking to streamline their HR functions without the need for extensive IT expertise.

​

Ultimately, the choice between JumpCloud and Breathe should be guided by your organization’s specific needs. If your priority is advanced IT and security management, JumpCloud offers the necessary tools and functionalities. However, if you require a straightforward, efficient HRIS for managing standard HR tasks, Breathe provides a reliable and cost-effective solution.